Jobs smell: real anger about artificial intelligence at US graduation ceremonies

Jobs smell: real anger about artificial intelligence at US graduation ceremonies

Washington: For years, American commencement (convocation) speakers could safely rely on formulaic speeches featuring inspirational clichés, autobiographical struggles, and sermons exhorting new graduates to “dream big” and not be afraid of failure. In 2026, there is a new safety rail: Mention artificial intelligence at your own risk.Across the United States this early season, graduation ceremony speakers invoking AI have been greeted not with polite applause but with boos and ridicule. Former Google CEO Eric Schmidt was harassed after telling undergraduates at the University of Arizona that they would help shape the future of AI — an argument that landed awkwardly among students looking into an increasingly tough job market due to automation, layoffs and hiring freezes.At the University of Central Florida, graduates booed when real estate executive Gloria Caulfield declared that “the rise of AI is the next industrial revolution.” The reaction was so immediate that the startled speaker asked, “What happened?” Before attempting to continue the game. At Middle Tennessee State University, music executive Scott Borchetta also drew criticism when speaking about the impact of AI on the creative industries. Instead of optimism, many graduates heard something else: “Congratulations, your replacement is scalable.”Hungama is more than campus theatre. It reflects a broader American backlash against a tech system that is increasingly seen as enriching billionaires and hurting everyone else. While the elites promise growth and abundance, young graduates (and their parents) are worrying about electricity bills, water supplies and vanishing entry-level jobs. Anger is now spreading beyond campuses to suburbs, farmland and zoning-board meetings — especially around data centers, the giant warehouse-like facilities powering the AI ​​boom. Just outside Washington, DC, in Northern Virginia, nicknamed “Data Center Alley,” residents are battling a proposed server farm over noise, electricity use, land consumption and environmental impact. A similar movement has spread in Georgia, Arizona, Oregon, Texas and New Jersey.It’s become such a hot topic that President Trump himself faced questions on it on Wednesday, only to emphasize that “AI has been amazing, because right now we have by FAR more jobs in the United States than ever before, more people working,” before immediately turning to Iran. Billionaires – from chipmakers to cloud providers to venture capitalists – have promoted AI as the next transformative leap in human productivity. They are not completely wrong. AI promises medical breakthroughs, faster scientific research, personalized education, better logistics, greater efficiency, and potentially trillions in economic output. “AI exists and in many areas it is smarter than humans. We have to get used to the idea that it will replace humans in many areas,” says Lil Mohan, a professor who teaches a course on artificial intelligence at the University of Chicago’s Booth School of Business.Yet critics argue that the benefits are unevenly distributed. Graduates entering journalism, design, software engineering, law, marketing, or customer support now simultaneously hear that AI will create extraordinary productivity gains – and entry-level work may shrink as software can draft memos, generate code, summarize documents, or design graphics.Residents near proposed data centers meanwhile hear promises of innovation and tax revenue, but see ever-increasing energy demand, heavy water consumption, deindustrialized landscapes and relatively modest permanent job creation. Public skepticism towards AI has increased as communities question whether technological acceleration exceeds democratic consent. “This is a very natural reaction of the graduating class because there is some small truth to the decline in entry-level jobs,” says Aditya Balu, who graduated from Johns Hopkins University in 2019 and is now an operations analyst in an AI unit at the World Bank. Yet the story is not simply one of AI-optimism or techno-pessimism. There is also a warning often omitted from Silicon Valley keynote speeches throughout history: Change causes harm. They redistribute power. They create winners and losers. And when ordinary people believe that the billionaire class captures most of the profits while the community absorbs the disruptions, anger arises.Which might explain why America’s graduates are screaming.

Zeen Subscribe
A customizable subscription slide-in box to promote your newsletter
[mc4wp_form id="314"]